Her

poter_her

Her is the story of a man who falls in love with his artificially intelligent operating system. The premise is definitely interesting, and combined with the great cast, had me really anxious to see this movie, and I’m so glad I did. I turns out to be one of my favorites of the year: both a great science fiction and romance film with a perfect balance of intellectual and emotional involvement.

Theodore Twombly (Joaquin Phoenix) is a letter writer for a website called beautifulhandwrittenletters.com, in which he lives vicariously through the relationships of other people. Like most of this movie, it is simultaneously sweet and heartbreaking. He is delaying signing the papers that will make his divorce from his wife Catherine (Rooney Mara) final. His friends all worry about how withdrawn and “mopey” he is, and in his free time he plays video games and has phone sex. He’s not exactly at the ideal point in his life at the moment.

sadtheo_her

This all changes when he gets a new operating system: OS1, the first artificially intelligent operating system. After answering a few questions about himself, the operating system activates and a perky voice introduces herself as Samantha (voiced by Scarlett Johansson). Theodore, in his loneliness and unhappiness, is amazed at how Samantha is so eager to discover the world. Samantha is happy to have Theodore’s help, and the two form a partnership that deepens into love. It is very strange at first, and even a bit after that (I’m not gonna lie, that thing with Isabella wierded me out a bit). This comes with the territory, and Theodore and Samantha try not to let the fact that he has a body and she doesn’t stand in their way.

An important aspect of this movie is how is depicts artificial intelligence and how society responds to it. It’s very interesting, as more and more people get OS1s, that others don’t really seem to judge Theodore that much for dating an operating system. He is troubled by the reaction of his ex-wife, but for the most part people get it. His friend Amy (Amy Adams) becomes friends with hers, and he and Samantha go out on a double date with a guy from Theodore’s work. Most people accept the operating systems into society and everyone lives in peace. This positive view of human nature (while even if it might be inaccurate) really stuck with me and I appreciated it. It reminded me a lot of Spielberg’s peaceful aliens in Close Encounters. It’s a very hopeful view for the future that had me questioning previous assumptions of artificial intelligence.

osstartingup_her

It’s going to be hard to address all of the aspects of Jonze’s depiction of artificial intelligence without giving too much away, but I’ll do my best to keep this spoiler free as I think it will significantly improve the experience of watching the movie. I feel like in most movies centering around artificial intelligence (the first one that comes to mind is AI, but if I remember correctly Blade Runner also fits this bill) is that even if they seem like humans, they just can’t feel emotions. They can seemingly replicate them exactly, but they never are truly emotional beings as humans are. In Her, this is different, or at least it feels different. It seems that even though Samantha is a product of the people who programmed her, she never stops growing. This is both in intellect and emotion. Through her relationships, she learns how to emote. Who’s to argue, really? I suppose you can never really know if anyone, human or otherwise, feels emotions, but if Samantha is highly advanced intellectually, it doesn’t seem that strange that she is also highly advanced emotionally. In most artificially intelligent beings, intellect and emotion are kept separate, but here is think Jonze really is combining them. How Samantha discovers the world and evolves along with the other OS’s is really ingenious and thought provoking, and it’s on an emotional level not just intellectual. This evolution sort of reminds me of 2001, though I’ll admit it’s a lot more straightforward here. It ends up in a completely different place than I would have guessed, but watching the movie it makes complete, beautiful, and ingeniously simple sense.

While the film does go into these intriguing science fiction issues, it is also a romance and a rather touching one. Though Catherine believes that Theodore has problems with advancing his relationships, and she’s right, it’s not as though he doesn’t try with Samantha. It’s great to see them come together and heartbreaking to see them come apart, but it’s a part of life that people grow and in a relationship two people don’t necessarily grow the same way. Theodore tries his best but eventually has to accept this fact, and this goes for Samantha as well. It’s very emotional to watch and both me and my friend who I saw this with were crying and laughing at the same time by the end of this film because it’s just so true. I don’t often cry at movies and I don’t know if I’ve ever laughed and cried at the same time, and even though it’s very personalized it’s the highest compliment I can give this film.

friends_her

Joaquin Phoenix is without a doubt, one of my favorite actors working today and perhaps of all time. He continually exhibits courage in his choice of roles and his turn as Theodore here is no exception. He is able to make him sympathetic but not pathetic, relatable, and most importantly of all, very sincere. Especially after playing a very closed off, hard to reach, and just generally unlikable character in The Master, it is strange to see him here doing almost the exact opposite, but it doesn’t stay strange for long because he does it so well. His lack of best actor nomination is one of the most disappointing things for me this year. The film essentially falls upon his shoulders, but Scarlett Johansson has an important part to play as well. She makes us believe that Samantha can experience emotions as a human can. Amy Adams and Rooney Mara both put in some good work as well, though they do not appear in the film as much.

You’ll notice that throughout this review I’ve compared Her to several other science fiction classics, and deservedly so, I think. It’s a great film that really gets you thinking, about both science concepts and humanity, which is really what sets the genre apart I think. I think and I hope that it will continue to be relevant as computers take up more and more of our lives. If the film has a fault it has a tendency to explain things to us (the characters will often spell out what they are feeling), but that doesn’t mean the larger background issues aren’t left for us to ponder. This didn’t hold the film back for me in any significant way, and basically everything else works perfectly. Her is a heartfelt examination of love and intelligence, and absolutely earns all the praise it gets.

sunset_her

“It’s hard to explain, but if you get there, come find me. Nothing will be able to tear us apart then.”

Long story short: 4/4 stars

For Further Reading:

PG Cooper’s Movie Reviews review
Cinematic review
Indiewire review

Advertisements

10 responses to “Her

  1. Definitely a great movie. Doesn’t quite crack my Top Ten, but that is only a reflection of the greatness that is the year in film.

    I also agree the Isabella scene doesn’t quite work.

    • Yup. It’s way nearer to the top for me though.
      The wouldn’t say the scene with Isabella didn’t work for me, it’s just that Theodore wasn’t comfortable in that situation (and let’s face it, most wouldn’t be) and that came across very well. It’s an example of Samantha getting more open in her ideas and Theodore not quite being able to keep up.

      • Agreed. The problem is Isabella. Because she isn’t getting paid, her actions are scene killingly weird. I found myself wondering who she was instead of focusing on Theodore and Samantha.

        • That sort of crossed my mind too. She and Samantha both think that she is helping Theo and Samantha out, but it makes a lot more sense that she would have ulterior motives.

  2. Nice review Hunter. One of the best movies of the past year, and for the main reason that it made me believe in this romance between Theo and his operating system, but never seemed weird. It was a tad bit goofy, but it wasn’t distracting as it definitely could have been.

  3. Nice review. This may be my number one movie of the year. It was incredibly real and surprisingly intimate. I’m a big fan of Spike Jonze and I think this is his best work.

    • Thanks! I still have a few more to see, but I highly doubt I will be able to get as emotionally invested in any of those. This is the first Spike Jonze film I’ve seen, but I’m definitely making it a priority to see more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s